Why are my Koi losing Color? Guide to Koi Color loss & Solutions
One of the most spectacular features of ornamental koi, and also the main thing that separates them from regular wild carp, is their fantastically broad color pallet. Unlike other species of fresh water pond fish, koi not only come in a range of shapes and sizes, but also countless color patterns, and it is these unique colors that draw most people to the hobby in the first place.
The main goal of koi keeping is making sure your koi are happy and healthy, which in turn ensures your koi maintain a strong and vibrant color throughout their life. Sadly, sometimes things can happen which can cause koi to start losing their colour, which gradually dulls over time. A koi that is changing in color is often an indicator of a problem within it’s environment they’re unhappy with which is causing them stress or discomfort.
Common Causes for Koi Color Loss:
- Poor water quality
- Poor nutrition (low quality feed)
- Predator attacks
- Injury, Parasites, or sickness
- Changes in water temperature
Although koi often start losing color due to the environmental problems above, sometimes it’s just natural and there isn’t anything you can fix. For example, koi will naturally dull in color as they age, so older koi will look much less vibrant in comparison to young and growing fish. Likewise, during spawning (breeding) a female koi may lose some color due to the stress of the process, but this is often temporary and returns afterwards so long as this fish is still healthy.
If your koi aren’t old or breeding, or the change in color is quite rapid, it’s best to take steps to try to determine the cause of the color loss before symptoms get worse. Keeping koi happy is our main job as fish keepers; and the happier our koi are, the healthier their color will be!
Do young Koi change color as they grow?
Yes! Many people are attracted to young koi as they often look extra vibrant and colourful, but the color you see is by no means a life-time guarantee. As koi grow they’ll change color and pattern, and some may go from patchy all over to totally one tone (often white) after a few years. This is normal and not something you can control, although you can sometimes make better predictions by looking at the fishes bloodlines before purchase. Only after 3-4 years of healthy growth will koi retain their mature color and pallet, so if you have a very young koi, the change you’re seeing could just be genetic. We always recommend purchasing older koi if you’re picky about the color you want, as young koi can sometimes be a real gamble. If you want to take a chance, paying very close attention to the bloodlines of your fish is important, as a koi from a weaker gene pool is much more likely to fade in color.
Luckily, however, there are still things you can do to enhance a young koi’s color as it grows, and if you get lucky with genetics, the end result will be even more spectacular!
Are koi more colorful in colder water?
Another yes! If you’re American and have visited any larger koi shows, you’ll notice most are held in summer. However, the biggest and most important Japanese koi shows are always held in Winter, and there is a good reason for this – colder water enhances color!
A cooler water temperature brings out a much more vibrant color in koi; intensifying whites, reds, and deepening blacks. The lower water temperature means koi eat less due to a slower metabolism, which brings more color to the surface. This rule holds true for koi such as Showa, Sanke, Shio Utsui, Sumi, and many other varieties of fish. In summer, most koi will fade in color, so if you notice your fish look slightly duller than a few months before, it could just be the change in weather and temperature.
How to Improve the Color of Koi
One of the most common reasons koi may be losing their color is due to poor quality food and nutrition. In fact, 9 times out of 10 a koi purchased from Japan (or elsewhere) that is changing in color is due to poor diet and/or conditions in their new home. If food and environment is kept to a similar high standard, there is a much higher chance the koi will retain their color into adulthood.
If your koi are still young (less than 5 years), the food you provide should be rich in high quality fats, protein, and extra vitamins. The fats will help the koi put on weight and make winter easier, and the protein will accelerate muscle development. Adult koi also need fats, but will be fine on a lower content diet so long as protein is within a range of 30-40% and comes primarily from an aquatic source. A problem with “budget” koi food is they’re not just low on protein and other essential nutrients, such as vitamins, their protein is often planted based, which isn’t ideal for growing koi.
As well as this, poor quality feeds will have more ash content, which acts as a filler that passes through the koi and contributes to waste in your pond. Selecting a koi food with a decent protein source (fish/shrimp meal), and good range of fats (4-10%), and low ash content (<10%) is recommended for the best growth and development.
High quality koi feeds which are designed specifically with koi in mind will also contain a wide vitamin and mineral profile, and often come with natural or synthetic color enhancers. Vitamins will help build a strong immune system, and color enhancers make the pattern of your koi much more vibrant.
For more information on the best feeds, check our full guide on koi food which includes feed recommendations and some useful nutrition guidelines.
Even if your water looks clear, this doesn’t necessarily mean you have good water quality. A gradual change in substances may not present as a change in clarity, so it’s always good to test water if you notice your fish are losing their color or acting strangely. Stress from increasing ammonia, pH, and changes in KH are all common causes of a loss in vibrancy and change in behaviour in koi. These kind of problems with water quality tend to occur in early Spring and late Summer, so regular testing throughout the year is good practice if you have a lot of koi in your pond.
If water shows no signs of change, which is often the case, you’ll need to be on the look out for changes in the behaviour of your fish. If your koi are unhappy with their conditions, they’ll certainly try to let you know – you just need to notice it! Koi that are constantly hiding, not taking food, or swimming in circles, all present behaviour common in low water quality conditions.
Water test kits can provide a wide range of measurements, and should help you determine if the color loss is due to water quality. If the problem is a rise in ammonia or nitrites (often the case), better filtration, more beneficial bacteria, and manually removing sludge may be necessary. pH should never be changed rapidly, as this is much more dangerous to koi compared to a high/low stable pH reading. Often pH will resolve naturally over time once other problems, such as ammonia/waste build up, are back in-check. For more information on testing water quality and what measurements to look out for, check our full guide on water testing here.
Something which will help improve water quality and overall water condition is optimizin filtration. A poor quality filtration process could be the cause of ammonia and waste build up that is placing extra stress on koi. This could be due to a filter box which is too small for your pond, damaged filter media, or lack of beneficial bacteria for bio-filtration. In terms of koi keeping, water filtration should be one of our main priorities, as koi will either thrive or suffer depending on the filtration you have in place.
If you filter box is the correct size for your bio-load (waste levels), changing your mechanical and biological media may be a good choice if you feel it’s under performing – a rise in ammonia being a key indicator here. Filtration can also be supplemented with beneficial bacteria products or activated carbon, which will help remove heavier organic pollutants that normal media cannot remove. Regular cleaning may also be required if you have a lot of debris build up, with both mechanical and bio-media suffering when clogged with “gunk”.
As well as good filtration, koi will need plenty of oxygen in the water to main their color and stay healthy. Low oxygen conditions will cause all sorts of problems, with a dulling of color being just one of many. If you don’t have any natural aerators, such as fountains or waterfalls, adding a dedicated air pump to your koi pond is recommended for maintaining stable oxygen content. This can also be run all winter alongside a heater to ensure koi have the best hibernation possible, keeping their strong colour into Spring.
4) Reduce all Causes of Stress
A stressed koi will begin to dull over time, so removing as many possible stress sources as possible is important for maintaining good color. Common causes of stress include changes in water quality, predators, lack of shelter, and the introduction to new environments. Koi are quite sensitive to changes, and much prefer a comfortable and stable living space. New koi introduced to new ponds, or koi during a heavy water change, may become stressed for a few days (or weeks) while things settle down. The arrival of predators to your pond can also cause issues with stress, as fish become more cautious about approaching the surface in case of an attack. Implementing predator deterrents, and providing either natural or man-made shelters is good practice to avoid this kind of problem.
Water should always be cycled in new ponds before adding fish, and it can also be de-chlorinated during heavy water changes. During times of high stress, tonics can be supplemented which contain natural ingredients to calm koi, but this won’t stop predators or fix poor quality water, so we only recommend this after the root cause is solved. Afterwards, however, stress relief products can provide a boost to koi which are feeling under the weather, helping dechlorinate water, remove heavy metals, improve their coats, and heal wounds and infections – all which help reduce stress.
Likewise, if your koi is suffering from an injury, infection, or parasite, you’ll see both a change in behaviour and a change in appearance. Sometimes injuries can heal on their own, but they’re best treated as they may often lead to infection or become a breeding ground for parasites. Treating both bacterial infections and parasites is common practice for koi keeping, and should be done at the first sign of symptoms. It is good practice to treat for both problems just before winter (hibernation) and at the start of spring for the best possible start to the year.